7 min read

Building a Crypto Company in the U.S. — The Past 8 years

Source: http://x.com/i/article/2054989759014211584

Even highly imperfect legislation can be 10x better than no legislation at all.

The CLARITY Act passed a key hurdle today, with bipartisan support advancing the draft bill out of the Senate Banking Committee after months of negotiation around key crypto market structure provisions (most prominently stablecoin yield).

I've had this post in my head for several months. Today seems like an appropriate time for it. I hope our experience with

@eco will offer some solidarity for fellow crypto founders, and some relevant perspective for those trying to understand why American crypto legislation is important.

The Past, Part 1

Most people don't realize we started Eco Inc. in early 2018. That was the tail end of what I call

Stablecoin Era 0, the beginning of Stablecoin Era 1. Our mission was then, and is now, to make money work better for people and accelerate money movement onchain with stablecoins.

We started by building Ethereum-native payment tooling. Our end vision was to build a new stablecoin with yield strategies governable by onchain data and governance, with our products natively supporting the stablecoin.

We built a lot of very good, first-mover tech in the first 18 months, but we made three market bets that were wrong or too soon: that Ethereum would scale the chain more quickly, that crypto wallets would build more mainstream UI/UX, and that stablecoins would begin to take off as an early crypto use case.

None of those three things happened quickly enough. The only one that really budged was the third one, when

@Paxos launched Paxos Dollar and

@circle launched USDC to join Tether in the market.

We eventually decided to pivot the product (but keeping the same overall mission). We still wanted to launch a new stablecoin or "stable onchain currency" but our initial infra wasn't usable enough to act as a compelling distribution channel for it.

Going into 2020 we designed the earliest version of the Eco App, a payment app and neobank based on

@USDC.

The Past, Part 2

From 2020 through 2023, we built the Eco App. We also launched an early version of the Eco currency/token, using the App as the primary distribution channel. Some of you know of Eco from this era.

To my knowledge, the Eco App was the first stablecoin neobank with true bank feature parity—bank virtual accounts, seamless USD-USDC onramping and offramping, yield on your sitting money (

but not too much

), a debit card backed by your stablecoin balance, a

bill pay feature, an

internal loyalty loop that took on a life of it's own. It's the product everyone is racing to build today (imo @plasma One has the best shot). It was also just

beautiful and

distinctive

(s/o @pklada ,

@JHCA1 and @workandco ). And the

onboarding model was incredibly effective. Pardon all the links; I'm still very proud of it.

We built the App during a highly uncertain time for crypto in the U.S. We hedged this uncertainty by choosing to build it regulated and custodial—as an MSB registered product, and by obtaining money transmission licenses for certain fund flows. We expected this decision would keep us on the right side of the (then still very undefined) line, whenever U.S. regulation caught up to crypto's inevitability.

This regulated approach empowered us to build proprietary fund flows for certain features, and to secure banking partnerships they depended on—bank relationships that at the time very few crypto companies could obtain. The App's technology backend became quite sophisticated, orchestrating transfers and payment operations across multiple channels (for example locking USDC and offramping/settling it with the relevant banking partners whenever a user swiped their card).

There was almost no out-of-the-box "Bank as a Service" infrastructure for a crypto-related product like ours back then. For every new feature, we had to go through months of diligence with a technology partner and a banking partner we needed to enable it. I still feel indebted to the likes of @lithic ,

@Plaid and

@TangoCard for the number of reviews we had to go through, and for their advocacy with banks and brands we needed approval from. There was no way we could have secured these relationships and built these features in unregulated fashion at that time.

2022-23: The Turn

Arms-length regulatory skepticism was the prevailing tone from 2017-2021. The crypto industry was still immature, but gaining attention quickly. Any statement from a relevant official, whether positive or negative, was pretty influential and newsworthy at that time.

Bill Hinman's 2018 speech was a prime example.

The 2022 demise of FTX was the straw that broke the camel's back. Regulators' tone had already turned much more cautionary during the 2021 crypto bull run, with the SEC in particular taking a more proactive and antagonistic enforcement role. But after FTX, the climate turned very hostile very quickly, with certain high-ranking members of Congress joining the fray (some of whom

still aren't happy

).

This put us on the defensive, quickly. We intended not only to launch our own token, but also to eventually give App users the option to access noncustodial features when the onchain tech, UX and yield risk became more mature and palatable. Amidst a lack of regulatory clarity—and accelerating regulatory hostility—we were constantly trying to hedge against multiple potential states of the world, and in any event to show good faith attempt to comply and build our product the right way.

Our best efforts proved insufficient if not futile:

  • In the first half of 2023, we were "debanked" multiple times (we became abit of a poster childfor this term) from our commercial bank providers—in one case having all money disappear from our online account with no notice whatsoever, in other cases being locked out of accounts with no notice.
  • Our regulated status, expected to be a moat, ironically became a vulnerability as multiple state agencies opened investigations against our fund flows (which never found any actionable claim, or any evidence to support one).
  • On the product side, we were constantly fighting weekend wars against short-notice data and compliance changes imposed by banking partners under pressure from regulators for serving crypto technology companies. We had to force users to redo KYC multiple times. And eventually we had to default users to bank accounts rather than USDC balances—the exact opposite of what we set out to do in the first place.

The writing was on the wall: Products like ours were going to be squeezed out of the U.S. market. Become a bank, or die. If crypto was involved, best efforts to benefit consumers be damned.

So we shut it down. Canceled the token, closed the app (after giving our users white-glove support to offboard), downsized the company.

The Cost of Uncertainty

Obviously that was a painful experience. But one of the worst feelings was knowing this technology is inevitable—a fundamentally better way to move money, and incredibly empowering for people—and that the the U.S. establishment was totally missing the forest for the trees. It was frankly infuriating to hear constant statements from regulators and members of Congress that I believed to be simply untrue, if not bad-faith.

As I look back, here is the tangible high-level cost of all that effort:

  • Thousands of hours, personally and teamwide, spent going through bank diligence (much of this for API products now available out of the box), adapting to tighter compliance requirements, and building payment operations. A moving target the entire time.
  • Multiple millions of dollars spent on legal and compliance fees, including voluntary forensic audits of every cent moving through Eco products in response to regulatory inquiries and actions.
  • An amazing level of unnecessary organizational complexity, jumping through hoops to ensure a token operated independently from our company, and to segregate certain fiat versus crypto fund flows.
  • Some very misguided public claims—which fundamentally misunderstood how our technology worked—against our company, which were cited in regulatory inquiries opened against us.
  • Even 18 months after we shut the App down, some of this stuff boomeranged. We got pulled into a couple bankruptcy actions for earlier service providers that had gone into liquidation, with their bankruptcy trustees claiming (with some success, unbelievably) that former client account funds should be treated as their assets rather than liabilities.

I estimate at least 80% of this to have been unnecessary if not wasteful expense. Now multiply it by the hundreds of crypto companies (not the tourists or the grifters) like ours—trying to build something real with crypto, in the right way, knowing the technology was inevitable and the U.S. should have a vested interest in its success.

A more forward-looking, pragmatic regulatory approach could have accelerated development and adoption of this technology to benefit consumers, and established the U.S. lead much earlier (but we could say this about many policy areas right now). We're fortunate the opportunity hasn't passed us by.

Reason for Optimism

I'm not writing this post to elicit any sort of reaction—only to acknowledge a policy milestone along the way, reflect on how far we've come, and support the need for the U.S. to embrace the opportunity of this technology. Most of this history is now, for better or worse, water under the bridge. Eco is thriving again, becoming the default platform for

programming stablecoin flows across onchain markets.

Blockchains are fundamentally a better way to track value and move money than what we have today. They enable more efficient markets, more financial autonomy and more economic opportunity. As a new technology and a challenge to the status quo, it has always been the case that crypto could prove to be both destabilizing or incredibly equitable. Any legislation must balance those forces. I've been in this industry for many years now because I believe we need to accelerate the accessibility and adoption of this technology in a way that bends the ultimate outcome toward optimism. We are at another waypoint now.

I hope the CLARITY Act moves swiftly through the Senate Floor to passage, without further regressive hold-ups by the big bank lobby. It's an imperfect bill—I believe the "rewards versus yield" debate and compromise fundamentally undermine part of the promise of stablecoins—but it's a passable one. And a critical unlock for not only the next phase of blockchain development and adoption, but the necessary evolution of how money moves and how efficiently financial markets operate.

The real and opportunity costs of ongoing uncertainty will be much higher.

Special thanks to the likes of

*@brian_armstrong*

,

*@iampaulgrewal*

,

*@milesjennings*

and many others for literally thousands of hours of tireless travel and advocacy in support of U.S. crypto legislation that the rest of us will benefit from.