Closing Fantasy: Notes from 2.5 Years in SocialFi
Source: http://x.com/i/article/2057094554092736512
After two and a half years, we are shutting down Fantasy Top.
TL;DR
- Every pre-seed and seed investor is being refunded 100%, dollar for dollar.
- Fantasy was self-funded for 2.5 years and paid ~$20M back to the community.
- The core lesson from 2.5 years: when a product is financial before it's anything else, it attracts speculators before users. We learned this the hard way with a TCG, but the same pattern is why most social tokens and most early-stage token launches struggle.
The decision didn’t come overnight. We spent months looking at every direction we had left, talked to people we trust, seriously explored a pivot, and ultimately came to a clear conclusion: we didn’t have the conviction to keep going. So we’re doing the responsible thing and ending it well.
This piece is a set of notes: what we built, why it didn’t work, and what we learned about social products, crypto, and tokens along the way. We weren’t the first to try this and we won’t be the last. If anything in here helps the next team avoid the walls we hit, the whole experiment was worth it.
What we built
For two and a half years, Fantasy was fully self-funded through revenue. While we raised 5.6M$ leads by DragonFly, no investor capital was ever spent on operations. Very few companies in this space get there. We did, and we’re proud of it.
The numbers speak louder than anything we could write:
- 2,665 ETH (~$8M) distributed to players
- 1,078 ETH (~$3.2M) distributed to heroes
- $12.2M in BLAST distributed across players and heroes
- 86% of players ended net positive when factoring in Blast rewards
Fantasy paid back the community far more than it ever took from it. That’s the legacy on paper.
Beyond the distribution, we built one of the most viral and engaging products in the social crypto space. We pushed forward new mechanics: mindshare scoring, prediction markets on social graphs, lighter F2P gameplay. We experimented hard and shipped fast.
It still wasn’t enough.
Why Fantasy didn’t work
We failed for one core reason: we tried to put crypto on top of a model that was never built for crypto.
Trading card games work. Magic, Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh, some of the largest and most enduring entertainment franchises in the world. People love them, collect them, trade them, play them for decades.
But every crypto TCG has failed. TopShot, SoRare, and now us. This isn’t a coincidence. It’s structural.
The greatest TCGs of all time were games first and assets second. People bought Magic cards to play Magic. The financial value of a card was a consequence of the gameplay’s quality and the community’s depth, not the entry point.
When you build a TCG on crypto, you flip that order. The card is financial before it is anything else. You don’t attract people who love the game. You attract people who want to make money from cards. Those are not the same people.
Once an economy is financialized from day one, every decision becomes harder. You can’t iterate on gameplay freely because every change moves card prices. You can’t experiment with new modes because they redistribute value. You stop building a game and start managing an economy. That’s the trap, and we walked straight into it.
We saw the trap and tried to escape it. Arena removed the ownership friction. Clout was a softer top-of-funnel. F2P was a free entry into the world. The prediction market pivot kept the social game but stripped the NFT layer entirely. Every move was an attempt to get back to “game first.” None moved the needle enough.
The Blast period made it even harder. Blast was so hyped at the time that a wave of users poured money into Fantasy hoping to capture a share of an airdrop fantasized to be in the hundreds of millions. We did around 70% of our lifetime revenue in the first month of mainnet. Starting that high made everything after feel like a decline. We weren’t building a steady-growth product, we were managing the comedown.
Financialization changes who shows up
This same pattern repeats everywhere in crypto.
Social tokens were supposed to revolutionize the relationship between creators and fans. Every attempt so far has failed. The reason is the same: real fans are not here to make money first. They are here for the artist, the team, the community. Putting a price chart between a fan and the thing they love changes the relationship into something else. The most active “holders” stop being fans and start being traders.
This is not a small problem. It’s the defining issue.
Crypto is excellent at creating incentives and aligning participants. That is its core strength. But we took what existed in web2, games, social, community; and assumed that bolting financial primitives onto those things would make them better. It doesn’t. It makes them different. In most cases, it makes them worse at being the thing they were trying to be.
You can’t just put crypto on top of web2 and expect the experience to scale. The financial layer isn’t a feature, it rewrites who shows up and why.
On tokens
This same logic extends from products to companies.
We never launched a token. We thought about it many times. We didn’t because we never reached a milestone where it would have been honest. Rugging is launching a token knowing it will go to zero like 95% of them. We refused to do that.
But beyond Fantasy, the more I look at token launches across this cycle, the more I think the mechanism itself is broken for most companies.
Letting any project launch a token whenever it wants, before there is a product or a market, is a bad idea. I used to think TradFi was over-regulated. I understand it better now. Those rules exist to protect retail from companies that aren’t ready for public capital. Crypto skipped that filter entirely, and we are paying the price across the entire space.
A token before product-market fit is poison. Every employee thinks about the price. Every user thinks about the price. You stop building and start managing sentiment. Even Across Protocol a great company with real revenue and real growth has publicly concluded that having a token hurt them more than it helped. That should land hard.
The strong tokens of this cycle are exceptions, not the rule: Hyperliquid, Pump, Jupiter. Real businesses, real revenue, doing buybacks. They earned the right to have a token by building first.
DePIN might be the structural exception, but most early DePIN projects launched at insane valuations that wouldn’t be possible today, and we still don’t have a definitive long-term success story.
Tokens, like financialized TCGs, become a vicious circle when introduced too early. They lock you into financial expectations that compromise the very flexibility a young company needs to find what works.
The investor refund
Every pre-seed and seed investor in Fantasy is being reimbursed 100%. One dollar back for every dollar in.
We can do this because we never had to spend the money to operate. The business funded itself. Investor capital was given to us to build something with a real shot at becoming a billion-dollar company. Fantasy wasn’t going to be that, and we didn’t have the conviction to spend that capital on a pivot we didn’t fully believe in.
We have too much respect for the trust we were given to burn it on a bet we don’t believe in.
To the heroes
Thank you. You let us build a game around your names and your reputations when nothing about this was proven. You earned more than $3.2M from it. We hope you feel it was worth the risk you took on us.
To the community
You made Fantasy what it was. None of these numbers happen without you. We tried to give you the most interesting social game in crypto, and for a while we did. Thank you for showing up week after week, deck after deck, tournament after tournament.
We’re sorry we couldn’t deliver the outcome some of you hoped for. We understand the disappointment, and we’ll sit with it.
For those of you who still believe there’s a billion-dollar idea hidden inside what Fantasy was, go try. The space is open. We will share everything we learned with anyone serious about taking a real shot at it. There are fundamental walls we ran into and you don’t need to rediscover them the hard way. Take a different angle, learn from where we got stuck, and build something better than we did.
That’s what we want this piece to be: not a goodbye, but a set of notes for whoever picks up next.
TCGs on crypto, in their current form, have a hard ceiling. Social products that lead with financial primitives keep attracting speculators instead of fans. Tokens before product-market fit are mostly poison. These aren’t just our problems. They’re problems of the space and they’re solvable, just not by repeating what’s already been tried.
We were not the first to try. We won’t be the last. Crypto, at its best, is still about experimentation, and experiments fail more often than they succeed. That doesn’t make the experiment any less worth doing.
Thank you to everyone who believed in this.