HIP-4 vs. Polymarket - who will come out on top?
Source: http://x.com/i/article/2042027241035411456
This article doesn't aim to address the technical differences between the backend/infrastructure for HIP-4 and/or Polymarket. I am writing this article purely to discuss how I believe the competition will pan out overtime and what impact it will have on the prediction market sphere as a whole.
Currently the only true relevant crypto native prediction markets are Polymarket and Hyperliquid's new HIP-4, which is why I am not including Kalshi in this debate, even though I am incredibly bullish on what they're doing off-chain. I want to caveat this article with the fact that I am doing this in one take, so apoligies in advance for any grammatical errors 👍
i. What is HIP-4 and what makes it relevant?
For those who are not in the prediction market space, HIP-4 is Hyperliquid’s new solution for outcome markets. Hyperliquid is making a giant leap into effectively accomodating all of finance on chain. The Hyperliquid team have seen prediction markets is a new asset class with infinite opportunity and are ready to go toe-to-toe with Polymarket and Kalshi in the fight for the volume on event trading. In short, the reason HIP-4 is so sought after, is because the Hyperliquid team have done an exceptional job with their other primitives. Their spot/perps trading infrastructure and token buy-back scheme has taken the web-3 space by storm and has created an extremely strong community backing towards Hyperliquid as a whole. Does this mean they will automatically be great for PM's? No, but the potential is definitely there and I believe with the team they have, Hyperliquid has a real chance in thriving in this space.
ii. It's still too early to tell
HIP-4 released last week with a couple markets. Truth be told, we're way to early to make a call on whether this product will be a real competitor to Polymarket. Polymarket has been around for years, building in silence and becoming a fairly recent phenomenom. It's very unfair to write Polymarket off just because Hyperliquid are releasing a competitor and to be honest, Hyperliquid has a ton of catching up to do as Polymarket is an extremely established in its sector.
I am personally very excited to see how HIP-4 performs once there is nearly as many markets as Polymarket has. It is of course, much easier to maintain a couple markets rather than thousands. Time will tell whether Hyperliquid's UI and infrastructure will be a match for Polymarket but as I said, the potential is definitely evident. Here is more information on why Hyperliquid is bullish in the technical sense (read the full article for in-depth information):
https://x.com/PDmytriiev/status/2052718154590113917
iii. Are they even fighting for the same pie?
I believe this is the most relevant point out of any. I would argue that there is space for both Polymarket and Hyperliquid to live together in this sector, both thriving in their own angles. Fragmentation of prediction markets were always going to happen. As more PM's get funded (every week it seems), more PM's will begin doing well and therefore an aggregated trading layer will become much more relevant. In the future I believe less people will be trading on Polymarkets or Hyperliquids native UI, but a aggregated solution will create edges across platforms. Automation and additional access to information which these native UI's simply cannot add, will become more sought after and that's when gaining an edge will only be possible by using tools which allow for that.
However, let's say this isn't the case. Polymarket and Hyperliquid has two very different target audiences. Polymarket has always marketed towards the retail market. You have seen advertisements on national television and IRL pop ups in the streets of New York. Hyperliquid simply doesn't care for that.
Hyperliquid has an extremely strong community within the web3 space, and their users will primarily already be within the crypto bubble. The two platforms will co-exist, of course, there will be cross over, but they can definitely both perform extremely well within the same sector, but just targeting a different market.
iv. The battle is now not just with predictions

Polymarket @Polymarket ·
We price the future. Now you can lever it. Perps are coming to Polymarket. Sign up for early access

756
1.3K
5.2K
[
28M
](/Polymarket/status/2046653304810156283/analytics)
Polymarket announced that they will be adding perps within their platform. This was a clear retaliation to the HIP-4 news and honestly, I think it's not a bad idea. Many of the whales in the crypto space trade perps, and having prediction markets in a perp native UI, will cut the need for a Polymarket for them specifically. With this move, Polymarket directly made a statement of intent - they are now fully competitors to Hyperliquid and vice versa. Ultimately it's a similar case scenario on the perps side as it is with prediction markets - the product which has been around for years in it's niche will be the better product for the foreseeable future and therefore Hyperliquid will "win" with perps for the time being. However, it's the long term which is more interesting. Now that they are at war with two seperate products, there could be a case where one product comes out on top with the veteran traders.
v. Growth through builder programs
Most companies know having a strong builder program has potential to infinitely grow your company to new levels. If a builder becomes a beacon for new users, the platform will be winning and spending nothing doing so. Examples of this are all over web3. The clearest example of being a beacon for a protocal is Polymarket itself, being by far one of the spearheads of Polygon's success.
Hyperliquid will have to create a support system for builders if they want to keep up with Polymarket. Being a builder myself, I know that Hyperliquid should learn from Polymarket, in terms of how great their developer relations is. Polymarket have grants, weekly rewards, ecosystem rewards - all that with great 1-1 support for builders who they believe will expand their foothold the most. I am yet to get a inclination of Hyperliquid's support but I am almost certain that they haven't got nearly the amount of emphasis on that which I believe is a setback before even starting. The amount of potential for growth by just supporting others that want to and have incentive to expand your userbase, is infinite and no one comes close to Polymarket in the prediction markets sector for this.
vi. Polymarket are underestimated by most
Polymarket have been getting a lot of critism the past month or so in regards to bugs in particular. I believe what most people don't understand is when you're moving as fast as Polymarket are, in the development sense, things will break. It is a part of rapid growth which is virtually impossible to stop. In the last month Polymarket have: - Changed their token (pUSD) - Majorly updated their infrastructure - Fixed multiple large bugs after the migration to v2 - Released a new builder ecosystem program - Changed their reward scheme & much more. Announced and thus begun working on: - Perps - Their own currency - An airdrop & much more. This rate of building is unprecedented and actually needed when they have competition popping up every week and want to become the ultimate prediction market which I believe they are right now. The level of hate the team get is far fetched and mostly hate-driven, and having worked with them for the past 3 months, I know they have a very cracked team and will create a very stable and seemless experience with time. So no, Polymarket are not going anywhere.
vii. Concluding thoughts
If I had to sum up the Polymarket vs. Hyperliquid debate in 1 sentence it would be: both Polymarket and Hyperliquid's HIP-4 will remain relevant even if Hyperliquid get it right.
I think it is very important to understand that fragmentation is ultimately very good for the prediction market industry as a whole. There is less risk of a collapse and competition will be extremely good for products to continue working hard and producing the best product they can with their position at the top being at risk. What is almost certain is that when Hyperliquid drop many more markets, there will be a surgeof volume on Hyperliquid. It's whether their infrastructure will hold up and whether the product is great, which will decide if the volume will stay or return back to Polymarket/Kalshi. However, due to the target audience differences mentioned in this article, Polymarket and Hyperliquid will not be fighting for the same pie and there will be space for both products.
Being a supporter of prediction markets as a whole, I am genuinely excited to see how the market share shifts play out and through competition and continuous adaptions, I am very certain prediction markets will continue evolving and creating new reasons to bet on your beliefs.