Was Circle Wrong This Time?
Source: http://x.com/i/article/2045557649975193600
The recent Drift hack is going to have a profound impact. I’m adding this update to help everyone understand the power struggle happening behind the scenes.
Think of the U.S. Dollar system as a massive Empire. Who’s the Boss? It’s the U.S. Government—and the Fed, the judiciary, the police, and the courts behind it. So here’s the core question: Who actually has the power to freeze assets?
Circle’s logic is this:
I cannot privately decide who is a "bad guy" without a court order or a police warrant. Even if the whole world is pointing at an address and calling them a hacker, Circle insists that until the legal process is complete, they have no right to press that freeze button.
Tether, on the other hand, is like a powerful General stationed far from the capital.
He’s tough and pragmatic. As soon as he spots a hacker, he doesn't wait for a red-stamped document from HQ—he draws his sword, shuts the city gates, and freezes the money first. This "act first, ask later" style saves money and wins public support, but to the U.S. Government, it’s a dangerous "usurpation of power." A strongman who can exercise life-and-death power without following the rules might freeze a thief today, but he could freeze anyone for any reason tomorrow.
The core of this conflict is: Who gets to hold the "Master Key" that can freeze assets in an instant?
If we compare the U.S. Government to the Emperor, then Tether is the Gutsy General, and Circle is the Rule-following Prince backed by the civil bureaucracy. Anyone who has read history knows: What Emperor would tolerate his core power being held by an uncontrollable outsider?
Right now, the U.S. needs to expand its stablecoin business, so they might turn a blind eye to Tether’s overreach. But once the market matures, will they still allow Tether to freeze funds without their approval? This is something everyone needs to think deeply about.
To take it a step further: this time we assume the hackers are from North Korea. What if next time it’s someone else? What if the attack happens with the silent approval of the U.S. Government? Look at the recent Chen Zhi case, where the FBI hacked into his Bitcoin wallet. When the Emperor and the General have different standards, who do you listen to? Who holds the actual final power?
Circle behaves like a typical American company—everything is based on U.S. law. The U.S. operates on a case-law system; if Circle loses this time and is forced to bypass the law, the U.S. Government effectively loses its ultimate control over stablecoins. Do you really think that’s possible?
Also, the way the community has handled this is totally off-track. Whether it was bad code or a leaked private key, the Drift project is the party at fault. Investors and LPs should be demanding answers from the project team!
The most bizarre part is that the Drift team didn't report this to the police or submit a freeze order to a court. They just shouted on the internet. That’s extremely unprofessional. You’re asking a company that survives on "compliance" to help you, but you won't even take the legal steps to make it happen. Instead, you just throw mud. Their move to swap USDC for USDT is even more confusing—is that just giving up? I don't get it. If anyone understands the logic there, feel free to explain!